Skip Navigation

Title Interpretation

When Deed Descriptions Fall Short

Title Interpretation

In Appalachian oil and gas title work, deed descriptions frequently prove insufficient to resolve property boundaries. With the exception of certain Ohio parcels established by the Public Land Survey System (township and range), parcels rarely follow straight lines. Current tax maps depict surface parcels only, and so are often of limited use in identifying underlying oil and gas parcels.

Smaller tracts appearing in the record today may trace back to early conveyances that lack clear back references or reliable context for their origin, i.e., references to the “W.O” (if you know, you know) or the “stone pile” that no longer exist. Deed language alone usually does not resolve those parameters, so deed plots prepared from metes and bounds descriptions, even if incomplete or non-closing, can provide critical perspective.

As acreage changes through successive conveyances, the geometry of a tract often changes as well. Comparing plotted descriptions across the chain—rather than relying on a single deed—can reveal whether a modern parcel actually fits within its purported parent tract or whether additional acreage may have originated elsewhere and have a completely different chain and could be subject to a separate oil and gas reservation. It is common for a current-day surface tax parcel to overlie portions of two or more oil and gas parcels with boundaries that that do not align with the surface parcel.

More complex files involving multiple parent tracts often require plotting each source tract and evaluating how they relate to the present-day subject tract by creating a merged deed plot. Where questions remain, historical farm maps can be especially instructive; once older tract configurations are identified, their footprints can provide helpful perspective on the shape of the tract under investigation. Additionally, state-specific editions of the Atlas and Gazetteer published by DeLorme (now part of Garmin) can be an excellent resource to provide context for locating roads, streams, and small towns referenced in deed descriptions.

While a non-closing metes and bounds description is technically a title defect, deed plotting combined with additional resources can provide effective tools for moving boundary analysis beyond assumptions and toward defensible interpretation.

Part of a continuing series of Appalachian Title Insights drawn from daily practice.

Have a Question About Your Matter?

These articles are for informational purposes only. If you have a specific legal question, reach out directly and CSW will respond promptly.

Contact CSW Legal Group